Saturday, July 20, 2024
Lawyers Run The WorldFTC Says Amazon Charged Kids and Must Now Pay...

FTC Says Amazon Charged Kids and Must Now Pay Parents


- Advertisment -spot_img

There has been some interesting events in an ongoing case between Amazon and the FTC.  The case started back in 2014 when the FTC sued Amazon claiming that it allowed children to make millions of dollars in in-app purchases without proper parental permission.  This was just months after Apple Inc paid $32.5 million to settle a similar case. Amazon, however, decided to fight the case rather than settle.

Amazon (like Apple) offered refunds to those who had these charges.  This, they claim, should be sufficient to resolve the matter, which is why they believe the FTC is wrong for continuing their claim.

In a reply brief the FTC argued that Amazon caused ‘substantial injury to customers’ and that the simple fact that the customers were required to seek the refunds for their children’s unauthorized in-app charges is ‘injurious in itself’ and that these consumers spent time and effort to resolve the situation.

The FTC specifically stated that, “In Amazon’s view, injury must be irreversible to be unfair, its ‘award-winning’ customer service allows it to engage in unauthorized billing with impunity, and rampant refund requests absolve it of liability rather than show the extent of the violation.  The mere possibility of remedying injury has never been a defense to an FTC action before.”

Amazon countered by saying, “Its requested injunction is nothing more than an attempt to impose hindsight-driven views of best practices without any balanced consideration of the net effects to customers.”

Essentially Amazon is arguing that at the time when this was occurring (years ago with the first-generation Kindle Fire) Amazon did not and reasonably should not have had to predict this problem.  While it seems obvious today that requiring a password on each individual purchase is important, that was not necessarily true at the time.

This is an issue common in the fast moving tech world.  Companies product products or services that have unforeseen issues.  Once the issues come to light they seem quite obvious, but should the FTC judge based on today’s standards?

The case is ongoing and it is difficult to predict what the FTC will do.  Amazon, however, seems committed to fighting this through the courts.

For marketers this is an important case to follow because it could set precedent on not only situations similar to this but any case that has a hindsight looking basis like this.

Pesach Lattin
Pesach Lattin
Pesach "Pace" Lattin is one of the top experts in interactive advertising, affiliate marketing. Pesach Lattin is known for his dedication to ethics in marketing, and focus on compliance and fraud in the industry, and has written numerous articles for publications from MediaPost, ClickZ, ADOTAS and his own blogs.


What's your opinion?

Latest news

#MADWOMEN: From Catwalk Queen to Data Diva

Hold onto your spreadsheets, people, because today we’re talking about Phoenix Ha—a powerhouse who ditched the glamour of Vogue...

AI Hysteria: Are We Heading for Another Dot-Com Debacle?

Hold onto your hats, folks, because the AI hype train is barreling toward what looks like a brick wall....

Juggling Data and Dodging Drama: Jon Watts’ Media Measurement Marathon

If you’ve ever wondered who’s steering the ship in the choppy waters of media measurement, meet Jon Watts, the...

U.S. Origin Claims Should Not be Based Upon Assumptions the Components Obtained from U.S.-Based Suppliers are “All or Virtually All Made in USA”

As noted in a prior post by an FTC Made in USA law fim, manufacturers and marketers cannot simply...

How Elon Musk is Rewriting ‘The Communist Manifesto’

Ah, the latest episode in the soap opera that is Elon Musk's stewardship of the beleaguered platform formerly known...

TikTok’s Ad Exodus: Navigating the Murky Waters of Geopolitical Gambles and Shifting Sands

Oh, how the mighty are faltering! TikTok, once the golden child of digital ad realms, now finds itself in...

Must read

#MADWOMEN: From Catwalk Queen to Data Diva

Hold onto your spreadsheets, people, because today we’re talking...

Juggling Data and Dodging Drama: Jon Watts’ Media Measurement Marathon

If you’ve ever wondered who’s steering the ship in...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you