Saturday, February 24, 2024
Lawyers Run The WorldIs That Non-Circumvent Provision in Your Marketing Agreement Really...

Is That Non-Circumvent Provision in Your Marketing Agreement Really Enforceable?


- Advertisment -spot_img

In California,  it depends.

California is notorious in the non-compete world for its virtual prohibition and scrutiny of individual non-compete and other types of restrictive covenant agreements, such as non-circumvention and non-solicitation agreement.

But what about when the agreement is between two commercial entities?

Rule of Reason

In August 2020, the Supreme Court of California in Ixchel Pharma, LLC v. Biogen, Inc., 470 P.3d 571, 573 (Cal. 2020), examined an agreement between two businesses and found “that a rule of reason applies to determine the validity” of business-to-business non-compete agreements.

California courts have generally invalidated agreements not to compete upon the termination of employment or upon the sale of interest in a business without inquiring into their reasonableness, they have invalidated other contractual restraints on businesses operations and commercial dealings only if such restraints were unreasonable.

Retraining commercial trade in some way is not necessarily illegitimate in California.  In fact, that court identified a multitude of ways in which contractual limitations on the freedom to engage in commercial dealings can promote competition, including, but not limited to, ensuring that marketing efforts are not exploited by contractual partners.

California’s “per se” ban on non-competition agreements is generally limited to employment agreements.  As long as a business-to-business noncompetition provision does not negatively affect the public interests, is designed to protect the parties in their dealings, and does not attempt to establish a monopoly, it may be reasonable and valid.

This case should be of interest to networks, lead aggregators, publishers, lead generators and general counsel.  Contact an affiliate and performance marketing attorney if you are interested in the implications of the Ixchel decision, or for assistance with professionally drafted affiliate agreements, ad network agreements and other performance marketing agreements.

Takeaway:  Commercial entities should strive to ensure that contracts with restraints on business dealings are objectively reasonable and otherwise satisfy applicable legal standards, including, without limitation, whether the agreement harms competition more than it helps by considering the facts peculiar to the business in which the restraint is applied, the nature of the restraint and its effects, and the history of the restraint and the reasons for its adoption.

Richard B. Newman is FTC TRO and asset freeze counsel at Hinch Newman LLP. 

Informational purposes only. Not legal advice. May be considered attorney advertising.

Richard B. Newman
Richard B. Newman
Richard B. Newman is an Internet Lawyer at Hinch Newman LLP focusing on advertising law, Internet marketing compliance, regulatory defense and digital media matters. His practice involves conducting legal compliance reviews of advertising campaigns across all media channels, regularly representing clients in high-profile investigative proceedings and enforcement actions brought by the Federal Trade Commission and state attorneys general throughout the country, advertising and marketing litigation, advising on email and telemarketing best practice protocol implementation, counseling on eCommerce guidelines and promotional marketing programs, and negotiating and drafting legal agreements.

What's your opinion?

Latest news

Before Influencers Were Cool: The Andy Batkin Story of Digital Darwinism

Navigating the tumultuous seas of digital marketing and ad tech requires not just a sturdy ship but a captain...

Much Ado About Data: The IAB and Google’s Privacy Performance

In the grand tapestry of digital advertising, Google's Privacy Sandbox has emerged not as a mere thread but as...

Now Pronounce You Retail and Tech: Walmart’s Proposal to Vizio

So, here we are, witnessing what could be the most unexpected crossover episode in corporate America: Walmart and Vizio,...

Touchdowns and Letdowns: The Super Bowl’s Marketing Circus Comes to Town

In the high-octane, neon-drenched spectacle that is Super Bowl advertising, brands embark on a gladiatorial quest for the Holy...

Nextdoor Knocks: How Heidi Andersen is Redefining the Neighborhood Ad Block

Heidi Andersen. Let's talk about her for a sec. She's kinda like that friend who knows everyone in the...

The Sound of Silence: Audio Advertising’s Answer to Hard-Hitting Questions about Fraud

In the grand, often garish carnival of digital marketing, audio advertising has swaggered onto the scene, promising to serenade...

Must read

Nextdoor Knocks: How Heidi Andersen is Redefining the Neighborhood Ad Block

Heidi Andersen. Let's talk about her for a sec....

Long Tail, Short Straw: The Myth of Niche Market Mastery

Oh, the long tail. It was the darling concept...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you