Lawyers Run The World Bad News: Advertisers Liable Under California's Anti-Commercial-Spam Law

Bad News: Advertisers Liable Under California’s Anti-Commercial-Spam Law


- Advertisment -

On March 4th, 2013, in the matter of Bank v. American Home Shield Corp., the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York ruled that California’s law barring commercial email advertisements that contain materially deceptive subject lines applies to parties who advertise in the emails, not just those who send them.

In addressing defendant American Home Shield Corporation’s motion to dismiss a purported class action under California’s anti-commercial-spam law, the court opined that liability under California Business & Professions Code §17529.5 is premised on advertising, not sending.  It also cited Hypertouch Inc. v. ValueClick Inc. in support of its decision and held that California follows the general common law rule that a principal is as liable for the acts he directs as he would be if he acted himself.

Also of interest is that American Home Shield argued that the complaint could not possibly meet the federal class action amount-in-controversy threshold of $5 million under the Class Action Fairness Act because the California statute caps recovery at $1 million per incident.  More specifically, AHS’ position was that the statute means per single email, irrespective of the number of recipients.  However, no California court has adopted that statutory interpretation.

Lastly, the court also rejected the argument that for an email to be subject to the California law the allegedly misleading information must be within the four corners of the message itself.  The message was misleading because the subject line read “Roof Repair Made Easy” and implied information about roof repairs.  However, the target of a hyperlink within the message actually led to a home warranty application.

Thus, the two were incongruent.  The statute requires a consideration of whether a recipient acting reasonably under the circumstances could be misled.

Information conveyed in this article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. No person should act or rely on any information in this article without seeking the advice of an attorney.

Richard B. Newman
Richard B. Newman is an Internet Lawyer at Hinch Newman LLP focusing on advertising law, Internet marketing compliance, regulatory defense and digital media matters. His practice involves conducting legal compliance reviews of advertising campaigns across all media channels, regularly representing clients in high-profile investigative proceedings and enforcement actions brought by the Federal Trade Commission and state attorneys general throughout the country, advertising and marketing litigation, advising on email and telemarketing best practice protocol implementation, counseling on eCommerce guidelines and promotional marketing programs, and negotiating and drafting legal agreements.


What's your opinion?

Latest news

The MediaMath Debacle: Is This Ad Tech’s Theater of the Absurd?

In the tumultuous world of business, where the unexpected often becomes the norm, the recent acquisition of...

Are you Confused about ChatGPT and Marketing?

In the ever-evolving landscape of artificial intelligence (AI), myths and misconceptions abound like phantoms in the night....

AdTech’s Secret Sauce: It’s Not All About the Code

If you're anything like me, it's all too tempting to get caught up in the glitzy allure...

Fortnite: The Ultimate Playground for Brands and Gamers

There’s a war going on, and it’s not just between the players. It’s a war for attention,...

The US Ad Industry Dodged the Recession Bullet

The winds of change often blow in unpredictable directions in the world of advertising, and as the...

RethinkFirst Unveils Seasoned SaaS Marketing Executive to Chart a Vision for the Future of Behavioral Health

RethinkFirst, a global health technology company at the forefront of the behavioral health industry, has made a...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you